Brand Truth or Web Truth: Which One Do People See?
A client of mine is one person. But the web seems to think he’s three people.
His website says one job title.
LinkedIn says another.
A page he does not control says a third.
Two pages disagree on the year he started.
The bio most people find first has not been touched since 2019.
He did not write most of it.
Other people wrote it over ten years, and nobody went back to check.
He is not careless. He has a team, a public profile, and more press than most of us will ever get.
Yet this still happened, because it happens to everyone who has been in business long enough to leave a trail.
I use two terms for this:
- Brand truth is who you are.
- Web truth is what the web says you are.
Google and ChatGPT never meet you. They read what gets written about you.
When the sources agree, they recognize you correctly.
When the sources disagree, they pick the version that shows up most, or they blend two (or more) versions into a person who does not exist.
Then a prospect asks the machine about you. And they are shown any one of those mashed-up versions.
This matters more for you than for most businesses, because you sell trust. The prospect cannot judge your work until after they have paid for it. So they study you first.
They do it before they contact you, in Google and ChatGPT, whether you know it or not.
If the web tells them something that doesn’t align with what they knew about you to that point, their trust in you just took a major step backwards.
They never book the call and you never hear about it.
It doesn’t matter that what they saw was outdated or inaccurate.
The web presented it as truth. And it was taken as truth.
But it was different from your brand truth. Your brand truth is the real you, the one that knows your audience and has the expertise they are looking for.
Joe Gannon calls the gap between who you are and what the world sees “visibility debt”.
Debt is the right word. It builds while you are not looking, and you pay it in deals you never knew you lost.
You’ve seen it. You've googled yourself. And Clauded(?) yourself. (Is that how we say it?)
You want to align the web truth and your brand truth. Eliminate that visibility debt.
It’s not going to fix itself.
So here is what you can do right now:
Ask ChatGPT who you are. Your name and your company name. Then do the same search in Google.
You want to see the ‘Four Rights’:
- Does it have the right person, not someone who shares your name.
- The right facts? No stale or wrong titles, companies, or profiles
- The right order, current work is current, history is history not the headline.
- The right story, what you want to be known for, your frameworks, your offer, your work.
You know the answers cold.
But the machines are working off whatever the web has on you.
Every inaccuracy on the web is your visibility debt.
Fix it where you have the most control first, your own website.
Start with your About page. Make sure it accurately represents you. That's your source of truth, where you want the machines learning from.
Do that, and you start closing the gap between your brand truth and the web truth.
How do I know?
Because I do it every week for dozens of entities. Through Authority Coded, we track what Google and the AI engines say about personal and company brands, grade every source on the web against their facts, and fix the ones that are wrong. The client at the top of this email is one of the people we do it for.
So if you search for yourself and the Four Rights aren’t coming up for you, shoot me an email and we’ll find where the gap is and what's causing it.
Your brand truth is yours, but the web truth is only yours if you make sure of it.